Israel, a (real) Expensive ally?

Since when do 'friends' lie and steal from you?

Charley Reese, Orlando Sentinel, January 11, 2002

Some people have asked for Web sites about the Israeli occupation of Palestinian territories. I would suggest you start with You will find extensive coverage of the issue, as well as links to other sites.

There are several reasons why all Americans should be interested in this issue. First, it is embarrassing that the government of the world's so-called last remaining superpower plays the role of the tail that is wagged by Israel, a nation about the size of New Jersey. Israel's influence in both the executive and legislative branches of our government is so pervasive that Israeli politicians openly boast about it. A few years ago when Egypt threatened not to renew the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty unless Israel signed it, the Israelis told the Egyptians that if they didn't shut up about the issue, their American aid would be cut off.

Now, please note: This is a foreign country telling another foreign country that it, not the United States, has the final say over American aid.Of course, it is also embarrassing (because of our silence) that the only nuclear power in the Middle East is Israel. The only country in the Middle East that refuses to sign the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty is Israel.

The only country in the Middle East that refuses to allow international inspection of its nuclear facilities is Israel. Yet all we hear from Washington is criticism of Iraqi leader Saddam Hussain's weapons of mass destruction. What weapons? He didn't use any in the Gulf war. Why is there never any criticism of Israel's weapons of mass destruction, which actually exist?

And now we are getting down to the areas where the Middle East actually affects Americans. Israel, armed to the teeth thanks to American taxpayers, continues to occupy Palestinian, Syrian and Lebanese lands. It, and it alone, is a threat to peace in that region, and regional war would inevitably affect America's real interest.

Second, Israel is the most expensive ally in the history of the human race. Depending on whose numbers you use, American aid to Israel has totaled $81 billion to $90 billion. There are so many monetary favors tucked away in the Defense Department budget that an accurate number is hard to come by. The $81 billion figure is the U.S. government's own estimate.

I like the way the British express big numbers. Instead of saying 90 billion, they say 90 thousand millions. That gives you a better idea of how much is involved. Let's suppose we could build a new public school for $1 million. With the money that has gone to Israel, we could have built 90,000 brand-new public schools or restored 90,000 public waterworks or bridges or any number of other infrastructure needs.

There is nothing in the Constitution that authorizes Congress to tax the labor of the American people and hand over the proceeds to a foreign government any foreign government, much less one that has blown up our diplomatic facilities in Egypt and attacked one of our Navy ships in international waters. An ally like that ought to come a heck of a lot cheaper than Israel.

Finally, our support of Israel's aggression and cruel treatment of the Palestinians is alienating not only the Arab world but the entire Muslim world. This hatred will eventually be expressed in the form of terrorism directed at Americans and at American interests. Terrorism is the poor man's way of waging war.

America's blind support of Israel's gross violations of human rights and international law will not only cost billions of tax dollars but eventually American lives as well. No lobby for any foreign country should be allowed to jeopardize American interests and American lives just to serve the selfish interests of a foreign power. America's government has only one justification for existence to protect the lives and interests of Americans. It's time to start asking Americans, including our elected officials: Which country are you loyal to?

Report Claims Israel Cost America 1.6 Trillion

by James Buchanan

A Washington D.C. economist Thomas Stauffer has made a serious attempt to add up all the costs to America that have resulted both directly and indirectly from Israel. Most Americans know that Israel today gets about three billion dollars a year indirect aid. The cost of these direct hand outs has been added up by critics of Israel before. One report (Ref. 1) notes that "If you add its foreign aid grants and loans, plus the approximate totals of grants to Israel from other parts of the U.S. federal budget, Israel has received since 1949 (up to 1999) a grand total of $84.8 billion, excluding the $10 billion in U.S. government loan guarantees it has drawn to date. And if you calculate what the U.S. has had to pay in interest to borrow this money to give to Israel, the cost of Israel to U.S. taxpayers rises to $134.8 billion, not adjusted for inflation... That's $116,205 for every Israeli family of five." To bring that amount up to date, 12 billion should be added for the period from 1999 through 2002 and another 14 billion in additional aid and loan guarantees are almost certain to be approved in the near future. (Ref. 2) Realistically Israel won't pay off its earlier 10 billion dollar loan or the brand new proposed $10 billion loan. (What Chutzpah!) That makes an additional $36 billion in addition to the $135billion or $171 billion total in direct aid.

This is literally an insane amount of money to give to one small nation. Israel only had a population of about three million until recently. Two million additional Jews, including a great many Communist big shots and KGB agents, fled Russia during the1990s for Israel. Many were running away from justice fearful of being prosecuted for several decades of crimes against humanity or theft from the Russian people.

The biggest cost to America caused by Israel has been higher oil prices that rob us every time we fill up our cars. Only Israel could have united OPEC countries against us and driven up the price of oil so rapidly. Stauffer believes the OPEC oil embargo in the 1970s "kicked off a deep recession. The US lost $420 billion (in 2001 dollars) of output as a result, Stauffer calculates. And a boost in oil prices cost another $450 billion." (Ref. 3)

Many Americans have been directly laid off from their jobs in the aerospace industry as Israel demanded that huge deals with nations like Saudi Arabia were cancelled due to Israeli paranoia. A deal to sell the Saudis F15s was nixed by Israel and cost America 40 billion dollars. Israel wants 30 Billion in 2007 alone!

U.S. Financial Aid To Israel: Figures, Facts, and Impact Summary

Benefits to Israel of U.S. Aid Since 1949 (As of November 1, 1997)

  • Foreign Aid Grants and Loans $74,157,600,000
  • Other U.S. Aid (12.2% of Foreign Aid) $9,047,227,200
  • Interest to Israel from Advanced Payments $1,650,000,000
  • Grand Total $84,854,827,200
  • Total Benefits per Israeli $14,630
  • Cost to U.S. Taxpayers of U.S. Aid to Israel
  • Grand Total $84,854,827,200
  • Interest Costs Borne by U.S. $49,936,680,000
  • Total Cost to U.S. Taxpayers $134,791,507,200
  • Total Taxpayer Cost per Israeli $23,240